Recovery playbooks
Where AP money leaks, and how to get it back
One page for each way a duplicate, an overpayment or an unused credit slips through, how to find it in the payment history, and what to send the supplier.
Duplicate payments
The same bill paid twice, and the ways it gets past the ERP's duplicate check.
- Duplicate payments from invoice numbers keyed differentlyThe same supplier invoice entered twice with the number written differently, such as INV-01043 and 1043, passes an exact-match duplicate check and is paid twice.
- Paying a supplier statement as well as the invoiceA supplier statement or account summary keyed as if it were an invoice creates a second payable for charges already billed and often already paid.
- When a reminder or copy invoice gets paid twiceA supplier chasing an unpaid invoice sends a reminder or a copy, it is keyed as a new bill, and both the original and the copy are paid.
- Duplicate payments through two vendor recordsWhen one supplier is set up twice in the vendor list, the same invoice can be entered once under each record and the ERP's per-vendor duplicate check sees nothing.
- A payment run or bank file sent twiceA payment file uploaded to the bank twice, or a payment run re-created after an error, pays every supplier in it a second time.
- Paying the same invoice by check and by ACHA supplier switching from checks to ACH, or a check reissued electronically, can leave one invoice paid once each way.
- Paying the same invoice on a card and through APA purchase paid on a company card and then invoiced to AP, or a supplier that charges the card on file and also sends an invoice, gets paid twice.
- A recurring bill paid alongside the supplier's invoiceA charge scheduled as a recurring bill in the ERP is also keyed from the supplier's own invoice, so each period is paid twice.
- Paying the full invoice after a deposit or prepaymentA deposit paid up front is not applied when the final invoice arrives, so the supplier is paid the deposit twice: once in advance and again inside the full invoice.
- Paying a pro forma and the final invoiceA pro forma invoice paid as a prepayment, followed by the final invoice for the same goods, is paid twice unless the first payment is applied.
- The same invoice paid by two entities or subsidiariesWhen an invoice is sent to more than one company in a group, or to a shared service center and a local office, each can pay it.
- Duplicate payments after an ERP migrationMoving to a new ERP creates a window where open invoices exist in both systems and can be paid from each.
- A reissued check when the original was cashed tooA check reported lost is reissued, then the original turns up and is deposited as well.
- Same vendor, same amount: duplicate or not?Two payments to one supplier for the same amount are a duplicate only if they pay the same charge; many are legitimate repeat charges.
- Duplicate payments in a foreign currencyThe same invoice paid twice in a foreign currency can show different home-currency amounts, so a match on amount misses it.
Overpayments
Paying more than was owed on a bill that was paid once.
- Paying a price above the purchase orderAn invoice billed at a higher unit price than the PO is paid in full because the difference is inside the price tolerance or the match was overridden.
- Paying for more than was receivedAn invoice for the full ordered quantity is paid even though only part of the order arrived.
- Freight charged twice or on a prepaid shipmentFreight appears on the supplier's invoice and on a separate carrier invoice, or on an order where the supplier agreed to pay it.
- Sales tax paid on exempt purchasesA supplier charges sales tax on a purchase the buyer has an exemption certificate for, and AP pays the invoice as billed.
- Volume discounts not applied on invoicesPurchases reach a contract price tier but invoices keep the base price, so every unit after the break is overcharged.
- Price increases above the contract capA supplier applies a price increase earlier, larger or more often than the contract's escalation clause allows.
- Late fees paid on invoices paid on timeLate fees show up on later invoices or statements and are paid without checking whether the original invoice was actually late.
- Paying the gross amount when the discount was earnedAn invoice paid inside its early-payment window is paid at the full amount, so the discount is given away.
- A credit agreed by email that never reached APA buyer or manager agrees a credit or price reduction with the supplier, but AP never hears about it and pays the invoice in full.
- Fees and surcharges the contract does not allowFuel surcharges, admin fees, small-order fees and invoice fees added by suppliers that the contract does not provide for.
- Software billed after cancellationA subscription keeps charging after it was cancelled, or renews for more seats than are used.
- Paying the wrong supplierAn invoice paid to a different vendor with a similar name, or to the right vendor's old account, leaves the real supplier unpaid and the wrong one overpaid.
- Supplier rebates earned but never paidSpend reaches a rebate tier in the contract, but the rebate is never credited or paid because nobody claimed it.
Unused credits
Credits and debit balances that suppliers hold and buyers forget.
- Finding unapplied vendor creditsCredit memos entered in the ERP but never applied to a bill sit on vendor accounts as money the supplier owes back.
- What debit balances in AP mean and how to clear themA vendor with a debit balance has been paid more than was billed: the supplier owes the money back.
- Credits left on inactive vendorsWhen a vendor is deactivated or no longer used, any credit on its account stays there because no new bill will ever absorb it.
- Credit memos the supplier issued but AP never enteredA supplier sends a credit note for a return or a price correction, but it never gets keyed, so the credit exists only in the supplier's books.
- Credits that only show on the supplier's statementUnapplied cash and credits often appear only on the supplier's statement: overpayments the supplier received but never matched to an invoice.
- Returns without a credit noteGoods sent back to the supplier are never credited because the return was not tracked to a credit.
- When the supplier keeps your overpayment as account creditSuppliers often answer an overpayment by holding it as credit on account, which only helps if the buyer keeps ordering and remembers to use it.
- Old vendor credits and unclaimed propertyCredit balances left unclaimed for years may, depending on state rules, be reportable by the supplier as unclaimed property instead of returned to the buyer.
Getting money back
Requests, statements, offsets and records: the work of recovering what was overpaid.
- How to request a statement of account from a supplierA supplier's statement lists invoices, payments and credits as the supplier sees them, which is the fastest way to find money the supplier is holding.
- Writing a refund request for a duplicate paymentA clear request with both payments, the invoice and the bank details for the refund is usually all a supplier needs to return a duplicate.
- Asking suppliers to confirm credit balancesA credit balance confirmation asks the supplier to state in writing what it owes the buyer, which turns a debit balance in AP into an agreed amount.
- When the supplier says it has no record of the paymentA supplier that cannot find a second payment may have applied it to another invoice, another account or another customer.
- Recovering by offset against open invoicesWhen a supplier owes money back and the buyer still has bills to pay it, the overpayment can be deducted from the next payment, with the supplier's agreement.
- Recording recovered money in the booksA refund received from a supplier should clear the vendor's debit balance, not be posted as miscellaneous income.
- Which overpayments to chase firstRecovery effort is limited, so the order matters: large, clear and recent items first.
- How far back to look for duplicate paymentsMost teams review two to three years of paid bills, balancing what can still be recovered against the effort of tracing old items.
- Asking for money back without damaging the supplier relationshipMost overpayments are honest errors, and suppliers return them more readily when the request is clear, factual and easy to act on.
- What evidence a refund request needsA supplier's AR team needs enough to find both payments and the charge in its own system without coming back with questions.
Prevention
The checks that stop duplicates and overpayments before the money leaves.
- Normalizing invoice numbers before you payComparing invoice numbers after removing prefixes, punctuation, spaces and leading zeros catches duplicates an exact-match check misses.
- Fuzzy matching for duplicate invoicesFuzzy matching looks for invoices that are similar rather than identical: close numbers, the same amount, nearby dates or related vendors.
- Reviewing a payment run before releaseA short check of each payment run before it goes to the bank is the last chance to stop a duplicate or a misdirected payment.
- Cleaning up the vendor masterA clean vendor list, with one record per supplier and complete details, removes the main cause of cross-vendor duplicates and lost credits.
- Verifying vendor bank detail changesEvery change to a supplier's bank account is confirmed by calling a known contact on a number already on file before any payment uses it.
- A monthly supplier statement reconciliation routineReconciling statements from the largest suppliers every month catches duplicates, missing credits and unapplied cash while they are recent.
- One inbox for supplier invoicesSending all supplier invoices to one AP address, and nowhere else, stops the same invoice arriving through several people and being keyed more than once.
- Month-end AP checks for overpaymentsA short set of checks at each month end keeps duplicates and unused credits from building up between larger reviews.