In short
- New fees appear quietly as extra lines and are paid with the rest of the invoice.
- Coding each fee type separately shows what is being charged and by whom.
- The contract's pricing schedule decides which fees are allowed.
- A claim lists each fee, the invoice and the contract term.
- Rejecting unexpected fee lines at entry is easier than recovering them later.
How the overpayment happens
A contract comes with a pricing schedule. Unit prices, freight terms, maybe a discount off list, maybe a minimum order quantity. What the schedule does not do is let the supplier invent charges later. Yet that is what shows up: a fuel surcharge line, an administrative fee, a small-order fee, an invoice fee, a portal fee. Each one is small enough to look routine, and each one gets paid with the rest of the invoice.
The overpayment usually happens at entry, not at approval. An AP clerk has an invoice with a matching PO for the goods and an extra line at the bottom. The match passes because the clerk checks the lines they expect, or the fee goes to a general other charges code. When the invoice has no PO, which is common with maintenance suppliers, courier firms and one-off vendors, the fee simply rides along with the service.
Approval thresholds help it along. An approver looks at the total and the supplier, not at every line. A fee that keeps an invoice just under a manager's limit never gets a second look. After a year of the same fee on every invoice, nobody remembers a time without it, and it becomes part of the expected invoice shape.
Renewals are a common entry point. A new price list arrives with fees folded into a section nobody reads, or a buyer agrees to current rates in an email that never becomes a signed amendment. The old contract says the price includes delivery. The new invoice charges a delivery fee.
Finding it
Start by coding each fee type separately. If fuel surcharges, admin fees, small-order fees and invoice fees all land in one catch-all account, you can see a total but not which supplier charges what. Separate codes by fee type, with the supplier name in the description, give you a report you can actually read.
Then pull the pricing schedule from the contract file and write out the charges it allows. That list is your reference. Anything on an invoice that is not on the list is a question, not a payment.
Look first at invoices without a PO, invoices paid from a summary statement, and card statements where the fee is part of a larger total. Read the line descriptions, not only the amounts. Fee names vary: handling, processing, documentation, energy, fuel, minimum order, small order, invoice, portal, expedite, restocking. Suppliers rename them when the old name gets challenged.
Run the fee accounts by supplier and month, and compare with earlier periods. A new line on a long-standing supplier is worth a look. So is a fee that appears right after a price change letter, a new portal, a change of account manager or a new buyer on your side. Ask the AP team to flag any invoice where the total exceeds the PO by a line they cannot name.
Asking the supplier for it
A claim works better as a document than a phone call. List each fee, the invoice number and date, the line description, and the contract term that limits charges. That might be the pricing schedule, a clause saying prices include all costs, the freight terms, or the amendment clause that says changes must be signed. Send it to the account manager and the billing contact, not only the collections inbox.
Ask for a credit memo for what was already charged, and for removal of the fee from future invoices. Removal matters more than the credit. A credit that is followed by the same fee next month is a round trip.
Expect pushback. The supplier will say the fee is standard, that it is on their website, or that your buyer agreed to it. Answer with the contract. A fee that is not in the schedule and not adopted in a signed amendment is not part of the deal, whatever the website says.
Keep paying the undisputed part of the invoice so the account stays current, and dispute the fee line in writing. Bring in procurement or the category manager if the account manager stalls. If the supplier offers credit against future orders instead of a refund, treat it as a commercial call: it only helps if you keep buying. Do not net the fee off a payment without checking the contract and getting advice, because set-off rights depend on the contract and the jurisdiction.
Preventing it
The cheapest fix is at entry. Reject an unexpected fee line before it is paid. Put the allowed charge list for each supplier in the vendor record, or in your matching rules, so a fee line with no PO line and no contract reference goes on hold instead of through.
Brief the AP team by name, not by principle. Show them what a fuel surcharge, admin fee, small-order fee and invoice fee look like on the suppliers they handle. Keep the allowed charge list for the big accounts where clerks can see it.
At renewal, compare the new pricing schedule with the old one, line by line, including the section on fees. Have procurement ask for a clause that says prices include all costs and that no additional charge applies without a signed amendment. Get buyer emails about fees into the contract file so that your buyer agreed can be checked.
Review the fee accounts monthly and compare with the same month last year. Watch the vendor master for freight terms and payment terms, since a change there often comes with a fee change. When a supplier removes a fee, note it in the vendor record so it does not reappear at the next renewal.
Questions
Are fuel surcharges allowed if the contract does not mention them?
Only if the pricing schedule or a signed amendment provides for them. Silence usually means the scheduled price is the price. If the wording is unclear, ask the contract owner or an adviser.
What is the difference between an accessorial charge and an unallowed fee?
An accessorial is tied to a service you requested, like unloading or a liftgate, and priced in the contract. An unallowed fee is a line the pricing schedule never provided for. The pricing schedule decides which is which.
How far back can we claim fees we already paid?
That depends on the contract, the jurisdiction and how far back your records go. Start with the invoices and contract terms you can evidence clearly.
The supplier says the fee is on their website. Do we have to pay it?
Website terms do not override a signed pricing schedule unless the contract incorporates them by reference or an amendment adopted them. Check the contract before you pay, and put the answer in writing to the supplier.
Updated Nov 11, 2026. Figures on this page are calculated by ERPSav from the definitions shown. The explanatory text is drafted with AI from those figures and checked automatically before it is published. General information only, not legal, tax or financial advice.