Recovery playbooks · Duplicate payments

A reissued check when the original was cashed too

A reissued check when the original was cashed too means a check reported lost is replaced, then the original turns up and is deposited as well.

In short

  • The replacement should not be issued until the original is stopped at the bank and voided in the ERP.
  • Stop-payment orders expire, so an original can still be presented much later.
  • Bank statements show both checks cleared; the ERP may show only one.
  • The supplier's statement will show a credit for the second check.
  • Positive pay with the original voided is the reliable protection.

How it happens

A supplier calls and says the check never arrived. The AP clerk looks at the vendor record, sees the invoice still open and sends a replacement. The original was never stopped at the bank and never voided in the ERP. Weeks later the supplier finds the original, deposits it, and the bank pays the original and the replacement. The ERP shows only the replacement, so the payment looks clean on the screen even though the supplier has been paid twice.

Another path is a stop payment that was placed but later expired. Stop-payment orders expire, so an original can still be presented much later. A clerk who did not know about the earlier stop payment may issue a replacement without checking the bank. A supplier statement will show a credit for the replacement check, but nobody applies it. The credit sits on the vendor record or in the supplier portal and quietly offsets nothing.

Common mistakes are easy to name. The clerk trusts a phone call, does not confirm the caller works for the supplier, and does not check the bank before cutting a replacement. The original is not voided in the ERP, so the vendor record still shows it as outstanding. A reissue is run as a manual check outside the normal payment run and never logged. The supplier deposits the original by mistake, does not tell anyone, and the duplicate stays hidden until someone reconciles the bank statement line by line.

Finding it in your payment history

Start with the bank statement and the ERP side by side. The bank statement can show the original and the replacement clearing, while the ERP shows only the replacement. Match check numbers, dates and payees. Pull the cleared check images and look at the front and the back. If the same invoice reference sits behind the original and the replacement, you have a duplicate payment to recover.

Ask the supplier for a current statement. The supplier statement will show a credit for the replacement check if the supplier has already recorded it. Look for open credits, unapplied cash and credit memos on the vendor record. Check the stop payment log and the positive pay exception file. A reissued check that was never logged is a common gap, so search for manual checks and off-cycle payments near the date the supplier reported the check lost.

Real situations look like this. A packaging supplier reports a missing check, gets a replacement, then finds the original and deposits it. A freight broker statement shows a credit for the replacement check that AP never applied. A contract manufacturer has an unapplied credit sitting in its portal. A facilities vendor cashes the original and the replacement, and the duplicate only shows up when someone reviews cleared check images during bank reconciliation.

Getting the money back

Gather proof before you call. You need the bank statement showing the original and the replacement clearing, check images for both, the ERP payment record, the stop payment record if one exists, and the supplier statement. Send the package to the supplier's AP contact, not just the sales rep. State plainly that the original and the replacement were both deposited and ask for a refund or a credit. Keep the request in writing.

If the supplier cooperates, get a credit memo and apply it to open invoices or ask for a refund. Confirm the treatment in writing and update the vendor record so the credit does not sit unapplied. If the supplier pushes back, escalate to your controller and to the supplier's account manager or procurement lead. Depending on the contract and the jurisdiction, you may need an adviser. Do not net the duplicate against future payments without a written agreement.

If the original was deposited by someone other than the supplier, treat it as a fraud issue and contact the bank right away. Ask the bank what it can do to return the payment. Positive pay with the original voided is the reliable protection, but it has to be set up before the duplicate clears. Recovery depends on the supplier, the bank and the contract, so keep notes and follow up until the credit is applied or the refund arrives.

Stopping the next one

Make one rule stick: the replacement should not be issued until the original is stopped at the bank and voided in the ERP. A Stop payment at the bank is not enough on its own if the ERP still shows the original as open. A Voided check in the ERP is the record that the original is dead. Require a second approval for every reissue, and log the reissue with the supplier name, the reason and the approver.

Track stop payments because they expire. Put the expiration date in the payment file and check it before any replacement is printed. Positive pay with the original voided is the reliable protection. Reconcile the bank statement to the ERP on a regular schedule, not only at month end. Review cleared check images for reissues and manual checks. Train clerks to verify the supplier's identity through the vendor master, not through an email or a phone number in the request.

Ask the supplier to confirm non-receipt in writing before you reissue. Keep the supplier statement, the stop payment confirmation and the check images together. Review old stop payments and clear the ones that no longer apply. Match check numbers to the payment run and flag any check number that appears more than once. Keep separation between the person who requests a reissue and the person who releases it. These steps catch the duplicate before the supplier cashes both checks.

Questions

What is a reissued check when the original was cashed too?

It is a replacement check issued because the original was reported lost, followed by the original turning up and being deposited as well. The bank pays the original and the replacement, and the ERP may show only the replacement. That leaves the supplier paid twice and AP holding a duplicate payment to recover.

Can I just cancel the replacement if the original clears?

Not after the replacement has been released. If the replacement has not been presented, stop it at the bank and void it in the ERP. If the original and the replacement have both cleared, you need to recover the duplicate from the supplier through a refund or a credit.

How do I find duplicate check payments in my payment history?

Reconcile the bank statement to the ERP and compare check numbers, dates and payees. Pull cleared check images and look for the same invoice reference behind the original and the replacement. Ask the supplier for a statement and look for an unapplied credit for the replacement check.

Does a stop payment last forever?

No. Stop-payment orders expire, so an original can still be presented much later. Track the expiration date and confirm the stop is active before you reissue. Positive pay with the original voided is the reliable protection.

Updated Nov 9, 2026. Figures on this page are calculated by ERPSav from the definitions shown. The explanatory text is drafted with AI from those figures and checked automatically before it is published. General information only, not legal, tax or financial advice.