In short
- Copies marked COPY, DUPLICATE or REMINDER are easy to miss in a scanned PDF.
- The original is often still in approval when the reminder arrives, which is why slow approvals and duplicates go together.
- Same vendor, same amount and invoice dates close together are the pattern to look for.
- The supplier's statement shows the second payment as an unapplied credit.
- Telling suppliers where invoices go, and answering reminders with the payment status, cuts reminders down.
How it happens
A supplier with an unpaid invoice sends a reminder or copy because its own collections clock is running. The message may arrive as a scanned PDF with a stamp such as COPY, DUPLICATE or REMINDER, or as a fresh-looking invoice with the same invoice number. If it lands in a shared inbox, an AP clerk may treat it as a new bill and key it without searching the vendor record. Copies marked COPY, DUPLICATE or REMINDER are easy to miss in a scanned PDF.
The duplicate often moves faster than the original. The original is often still in approval when the reminder arrives, which is why slow approvals and duplicates go together. A packaging supplier sends a reminder while the original sits with a plant manager; the reminder reaches AP through a general inbox and is entered as new. The original is approved later, and both are scheduled. A freight broker or maintenance supplier can create the same result when a copy is sent to another contact.
The pattern is usually visible. Same vendor, same amount and invoice dates close together are the pattern to look for. Sometimes the supplier's statement shows the second payment as an unapplied credit. The AP team sees a clean payment run and misses that the vendor record has an open credit. The mistake is not a rare systems failure; it is a routine intake and approval timing problem.
Finding it in your payment history
Start with vendor-level review rather than a random scan. Pull payment history for suppliers that send reminders, then match each payment to an invoice number, invoice date and amount. Look for same vendor, same amount and invoice dates close together. Include payments to the same supplier under slight name variations, because a copy may be keyed under a different vendor record.
Open the scanned images, not just the entry fields. A copy can carry a faint stamp, a different remit-to address or a header that says reminder. Train reviewers to read the PDF and compare it with the invoice already in the vendor record. If the invoice number is the same, the entry should stop and be linked to the existing bill.
Reconcile supplier statements to your payment history. The supplier's statement shows the second payment as an unapplied credit. That credit is a useful signal: if the supplier has cash from you that it cannot match to an invoice, check whether you paid the original and the copy. Also look at the approval queue for an original still open after a copy has been paid.
Keep a simple recovery log for every suspect item: supplier, invoice number, payment date, payment method and current status. The log helps the controller see patterns and helps AP avoid paying again while a refund or credit is being discussed. It also gives the supplier a clear reference when you ask for a refund.
Getting the money back
Gather proof before you call. Use the payment history, remittance advice, check or bank reference, the invoice copy and the supplier statement. Identify the original invoice and the copy, and note the payment that should not have been made. Ask the supplier's accounts receivable team to confirm what it has received and how it applied the payment.
Make a clear request: refund the duplicate amount or apply it as a credit to open invoices. Put the request in writing and include the payment details and invoice numbers. If the supplier offers a credit, confirm in writing which invoices it will offset and when. Do not assume the credit will be applied automatically; a credit that sits unapplied is easy to lose.
If the supplier agrees to a refund, track it through to the bank and match it to the recovery log. If it offers a credit instead, compare the value of using that credit against your own cost of funds and your need for cash. Contract terms and jurisdiction affect your options, so take advice if the supplier disputes the duplicate.
Keep the vendor record clean. Note the resolution, close the duplicate bill and prevent the credit from being used twice. Tell the approver and the buyer what happened so the same supplier does not get a second copy paid during the discussion.
Stopping the next one
Tell suppliers where invoices go and what to include. A clear intake address, a clear subject line and a requirement to quote the invoice number reduce the chance that a reminder is treated as a new bill. Telling suppliers where invoices go, and answering reminders with the payment status, cuts reminders down. When a supplier asks about an invoice, reply with its status: received, in approval, scheduled or paid.
Slow approvals create the opening for duplicates. The original is often still in approval when the reminder arrives, which is why slow approvals and duplicates go together. Set an approval routine that flags invoices sitting too long and gives AP a way to answer the supplier before a copy is sent. If approval will take time, tell the supplier the invoice is in process.
Control the intake. Route all invoice copies to a central inbox, mark them as copies and require the clerk to search the vendor record before keying. Use same vendor, same amount and invoice dates close together as a signal to stop and check. If the invoice number already exists, link the copy to the open bill rather than creating a new one.
Train the team on the reminders that look most innocent: a supplier chasing a payment, a copy sent to another contact, or a statement showing an unapplied credit. Review a sample of vendor statements each period and follow up on credits. The goal is not to block supplier reminders but to make sure every reminder is answered from the vendor record.
Questions
What do I do if a supplier sends a reminder for an invoice we already paid?
Check the vendor record and payment history before responding. If the invoice is paid, send the supplier the payment date, amount and remittance reference so it can apply the cash. If a copy was also paid, ask for a refund or a credit and record the request in your recovery log.
How do I find duplicate payments in accounts payable?
Pull payment history by supplier and look for same vendor, same amount and invoice dates close together. Read the scanned invoices for COPY, DUPLICATE or REMINDER stamps, and reconcile supplier statements for unapplied credits. Check the approval queue for an original still open after a copy has been paid.
Should I accept a supplier credit instead of a refund?
A credit can be practical if you will use it soon with the same supplier. Compare the value of using the credit with your own cost of funds and your cash needs. Get written confirmation of which invoices the credit will offset, and follow up until it is applied.
How can we stop copy invoices from being entered as new bills?
Give suppliers a clear invoice address and answer reminders with the payment status. Require AP clerks to search the vendor record by invoice number, amount and supplier before keying a bill. Mark copies at intake and link them to the original rather than creating a new entry.
Updated Nov 7, 2026. Figures on this page are calculated by ERPSav from the definitions shown. The explanatory text is drafted with AI from those figures and checked automatically before it is published. General information only, not legal, tax or financial advice.