In short
- Rent, leases, subscriptions and service contracts are the usual cases.
- The recurring entry and the keyed invoice often carry different reference numbers, so duplicate checks miss them.
- Looking for two payments to the same vendor of the same amount in the same period finds them.
- A charge should be either scheduled or keyed from invoices, not both.
- Schedules also outlive contracts; each one needs an end date and an owner.
How it happens
Rent, leases, subscriptions and service contracts are the usual cases. The AP team sets up a recurring bill because the obligation is predictable, then someone in the same team keys the supplier's invoice when it arrives. The schedule entry carries the schedule's own reference. The keyed invoice carries the supplier's invoice number. The two records live side by side, and the payment run releases both.
A packaging supplier sends a monthly invoice for a service contract. The AP team has that service on a recurring bill schedule. The clerk who opens the supplier's invoice does not see the schedule, because the schedule was set up by a different person or in a different period. The invoice is keyed, approved and paid. The scheduled bill is also paid. The invoice number on the keyed entry does not match the schedule reference, so a duplicate check that looks only at invoice numbers passes both.
The same pattern appears with a lease paid on a schedule and then keyed from the landlord's invoice, and with a subscription renewed on a schedule while the renewal invoice is entered by a shared inbox. Schedules also outlive contracts. A service contract ends, but the recurring bill remains active because no one owns the end date. The supplier may stop invoicing, yet the schedule keeps paying, or the supplier may invoice and the schedule pays twice.
In plain terms, a charge scheduled as a recurring bill in the ERP is also keyed from the supplier's own invoice, so each period is paid twice. The common thread is not a single careless clerk. It is two valid AP processes for one obligation: the schedule and the invoice. When both run, each period is paid twice.
Finding it in your payment history
Start with payment history, not the invoice register. Pull payments by vendor and period and look for two payments to the same vendor of the same amount in the same period. Looking for two payments to the same vendor of the same amount in the same period finds them. That simple pattern finds the recurring bill and the keyed invoice even when their reference numbers differ. Look across payment runs, not just the current month, because the two payments can land in different runs.
Use the vendor record as a cross-check. List vendors with active recurring bills, then compare that list with the payments made to the same vendors in the period. A vendor that has both an active schedule and keyed invoices is a candidate. Do not rely on invoice-number matching alone, because the schedule reference and the supplier invoice number are different by design.
Look for the same amount paid twice, not just similar amounts. The scheduled charge and the keyed invoice often match exactly, while other vendor activity varies. Check the payment date near the scheduled date and confirm whether the keyed invoice was already covered by the schedule. A supplier statement can help: if the supplier shows one invoice outstanding while your payment history shows two payments, the extra payment is visible.
A worked case: a janitorial supplier invoices a monthly service. The payment history shows the scheduled amount and the keyed invoice amount to the same vendor in the same period, with different references. The invoice register shows one invoice number. The payment history shows two outgoing payments. That is the record to investigate.
Getting the money back
Gather the scheduled payment reference, the keyed invoice reference and the payment date from your history. Send the supplier both references and ask whether the payment was applied once or twice. Ask for a refund or a credit memo, whichever the supplier's process supports. Keep the request and the supplier's response with the vendor record.
If the supplier applies the extra payment to another open invoice, track that credit. Do not close the case until the credit appears on a later statement or is applied to a specific invoice. A credit that is not tracked can become an unapplied vendor credit and be lost again. Reconcile the vendor statement to your payment history after the supplier responds.
Not every duplicate is recoverable. The outcome depends on the contract, the supplier's records and the jurisdiction. If the supplier disputes the payment, escalate to the controller with the two payment records and the contract terms. Where the contract or local rules matter, take advice from an adviser. For any refund versus credit decision, compare the supplier's terms with your own cost of funds.
Stopping the next one
Set one rule: a charge should be either scheduled or keyed from invoices, not both. Write the rule into vendor onboarding and into the month-end close checklist. When a recurring bill is created, mark the vendor and the obligation so the AP team knows not to key the supplier's invoice for the same charge.
Give every schedule an end date and an owner. Schedules also outlive contracts; each one needs an end date and an owner. Review active schedules against contracts each period. When a contract ends, stop the schedule before the next payment run. When a contract renews, confirm whether the schedule or the invoice will be the source of truth, and tell the shared inbox and the approvers.
Change the duplicate check to look at vendor, amount and period, not only invoice number. The recurring entry and the keyed invoice often carry different reference numbers, so duplicate checks miss them. A period-based review catches the pair. Keep the review separate from the payment run so a clerk cannot approve a keyed invoice and release the schedule in the same step without seeing both.
Train the team on the usual cases: rent, leases, subscriptions and service contracts. A new AP clerk should learn to ask whether a supplier is already on a schedule before keying the invoice. A controller should see the list of active schedules and the owners at each close. The goal is not more checks; it is one clear owner for each recurring obligation and one source for each payment.
Questions
How do I find a recurring bill that was also keyed from the supplier invoice?
Pull payments by vendor and period and look for two payments to the same vendor of the same amount in the same period. Compare that result with the list of active recurring bills. A matching pair with different references is the pattern to investigate.
What is the difference between a recurring bill and a duplicate payment?
A recurring bill is a scheduled charge for a predictable obligation. A duplicate payment is a second payment for the same obligation. The duplicate can come from keying the supplier invoice when the schedule already covers the charge.
Should I schedule recurring bills or enter supplier invoices?
Use one method for each charge: the schedule or the supplier invoice, not both. Rent, leases, subscriptions and service contracts are the usual cases for a schedule. Keyed invoices work when the amount or timing varies and no schedule exists.
Can I recover a duplicate payment if the supplier already applied it to another invoice?
Ask the supplier for a credit memo or refund and track the credit until it appears on a statement. Recovery depends on the contract, the supplier's records and the jurisdiction. Escalate to the controller if the supplier disputes it, and take advice where the contract or local rules matter.
Updated Nov 9, 2026. Figures on this page are calculated by ERPSav from the definitions shown. The explanatory text is drafted with AI from those figures and checked automatically before it is published. General information only, not legal, tax or financial advice.