In short
- Send the bank proof: trace number, check image or wire reference, and the date it cleared.
- Ask the supplier to search unapplied cash and other customer accounts for the amount and date.
- Payments to the wrong legal entity or an old remit-to address are common.
- If it went to a closed or wrong account, the paying bank can trace it.
- Keep the case open with dated follow-ups until the payment is located.
When this applies
This applies when a supplier's statement or AP contact says an invoice is still open after your bank shows the payment cleared. It also applies when the supplier finds a payment but cannot match it to the invoice you intended, or when the supplier's records show no cash at all for the date and amount you paid. A packaging supplier may call about a repeat payment that it cannot find. A freight supplier may say the payment never arrived while your bank statement says otherwise. The supplier is not usually accusing you of anything. Its cash team is looking at a different set of records, and the payment may be sitting somewhere it has not checked.
The trigger can come from either side. Your AP team may see an open item on the vendor record after the payment run, or the supplier may send a statement that still shows the invoice as due. The case is harder when the payment went to an old remit-to address, a different legal entity or a bank account the supplier has since closed. It is also harder when the remittance advice did not reach the supplier's cash team, even though the money left your bank.
Treat the call as a tracing case, not a request to pay again. Keep the vendor record open, note who said what and when, and do not release a replacement payment while the original is unresolved. A supplier that cannot find a repeat payment may have applied it to another invoice, another account or another customer. That is normal in shared service centers that handle many entities and bank accounts. Your job is to give the supplier enough proof to search the right place.
Step by step
Start with your own bank and vendor record. Confirm the payment cleared, not just that it was issued. Pull the bank proof: trace number, check image or wire reference, and the date it cleared. Match that proof to the vendor record and to the remittance advice you sent. If the payment was issued but not cleared, stop and treat it as a bank or payment-run issue before you contact the supplier again.
Send the proof to the supplier's AP or cash team, not the sales rep. Ask the supplier to search unapplied cash and other customer accounts for the amount and date. Give the legal entity you paid, the remit-to address you used and the invoice numbers from your remittance. Ask the supplier to confirm whether it applied the payment to another invoice, another account or another customer. That single request solves many cases because the cash is often sitting in a suspense or unapplied balance.
If the supplier checks those places and still cannot find the payment, ask where the money went. If it went to a closed or wrong account, the paying bank can trace it. Contact your bank with the trace number or wire reference and ask for a trace or recall. Keep the supplier informed while the bank works. Do not send a replacement payment just to clear the statement. If the supplier agrees to credit the open invoice while the trace runs, get that in writing.
Keep the case open with dated follow-ups until the payment is located. Set the next contact date before you close the call. Record what the supplier checked, who checked it and what they found. If the supplier later locates the payment, ask for a credit memo or a clear reallocation and confirm which invoices are now settled. Close the case only when the vendor record and the supplier's record agree.
What to send
Send bank proof first. For a check, send the check image and the date it cleared. For an ACH payment, send the trace number and the date it cleared. For a wire, send the wire reference and the date it cleared. Add the vendor record showing the payment you posted, but keep it short. The supplier needs the payment details, not your whole ledger.
Include a clean Remittance advice that lists the invoices you intended to pay and the amount applied to each. If you sent the remittance to an old address or to a person who has left, say so. Send the same pack to the supplier's AP or cash team and ask for a named contact. A statement alone is weak evidence because it shows what you owe, not what you paid.
Ask the supplier to check Unapplied cash and other customer accounts for the amount and date. Give the legal entity and the remit-to address exactly as they appear on the payment. If the supplier operates through different entities, ask the cash team to search every relevant account, not only the entity that sent the statement. Keep personal data out of the pack. Send only what the supplier needs to trace the money.
If the supplier says it has no record after receiving the pack, ask for a written response that lists where it searched. That response helps your bank trace and helps you decide the next step. It also stops the case from being reopened by a different person who has not seen the file. Use the same pack for every follow-up so the supplier can compare details.
Common problems
A common mistake is to resend the payment when the supplier says it cannot find it. That can create a duplicate if the original is later found in unapplied cash. Another is to send proof to the sales rep, who may not pass it to the cash team. Send it to the AP contact and copy the person who raised the query. Keep the vendor record open and note the replacement hold.
Suppliers often apply cash to the oldest open invoice, not the invoice you intended. The remittance advice should prevent that, but it only works if the supplier's cash team receives it. A packaging supplier may apply a payment to a different entity because the remit-to address changed. A freight supplier may post the cash to another customer with a similar name. Ask the supplier to search by amount and date, not only by invoice number.
Payments to the wrong legal entity or an old remit-to address are common. So are payments to a closed bank account. If the money went to a closed or wrong account, the paying bank can trace it. Give the bank the trace number or wire reference and the date it cleared. Ask the supplier to confirm the account it expected and the entity that should have received the money. Do not change bank details on a phone call alone. Verify any new bank details through a known contact before you act.
Keep dated follow-ups. A case that goes quiet is harder to recover because the bank trace process and the supplier's records move on. If the supplier cannot find the payment after a reasonable search, escalate to the supplier's AP manager or controller. Ask for a written position on the open invoice. If the contract, the jurisdiction or an adviser affects your options, get that advice before you write off the payment or send a replacement.
Questions
What should I send when a supplier says it has no record of our payment?
Send the bank proof first: the trace number, check image or wire reference, and the date it cleared. Add the remittance advice and the vendor record showing the payment you posted. Ask the supplier to search unapplied cash and other customer accounts for the amount and date. Keep the pack short and send it to the supplier's AP or cash team.
Can a supplier apply our payment to another invoice or customer account?
Yes. A supplier that cannot find a payment may have applied it to another invoice, another account or another customer. Ask it to search unapplied cash and other customer accounts by amount and date, not only by invoice number. If the supplier operates through different entities, ask the cash team to search every relevant account.
How long should we wait before sending a replacement payment?
Do not send a replacement while the original payment is unresolved. Keep the case open with dated follow-ups until the payment is located or the supplier agrees in writing to credit the open invoice. Any deadline that applies depends on the contract, the jurisdiction or an adviser, so check before you write off the payment.
What if the payment went to a closed or wrong bank account?
Contact your paying bank with the trace number or wire reference and the date it cleared. The paying bank can trace the payment. Tell the supplier what you have asked the bank to do and keep the vendor record open. Do not change bank details based on a phone call alone; verify them through a known contact.
Updated Nov 14, 2026. Figures on this page are calculated by ERPSav from the definitions shown. The explanatory text is drafted with AI from those figures and checked automatically before it is published. General information only, not legal, tax or financial advice.