In short
- Small differences inside tolerance are paid without review and add up across many invoices.
- Supplier price files that are out of date against the contract cause repeated small overcharges.
- Comparing paid invoice prices with PO and contract prices shows the gap by supplier.
- The claim is the price difference times the quantity, with the PO or contract as evidence.
- Tight tolerances for high-volume items and updated PO prices prevent it.
How the overpayment happens
Price above the PO usually starts with a small gap that looks harmless. A packaging supplier sends an invoice with a unit price above the PO by a small amount. The quantity matches the receipt. The invoice sits inside the invoice tolerance, so the match clears and the payment goes out. Nobody reviews the gap because it looks like noise. Across many invoices, that noise becomes real money.
Supplier price files that are out of date against the contract cause the same pattern. The supplier's billing system still carries an old list price, or a buyer agreed a new price and did not update the PO. Every invoice for that item arrives high. If the item is high volume, the unit gap repeats on every delivery. AP sees a clean receipt and a clean quantity, so the invoice passes.
Overrides make it worse. A clerk sees a price exception and clears it to avoid a hold, or a buyer says the increase is fine and asks AP to pay. The PO is never changed. The next invoice comes in at the same higher price, and the override becomes the habit. The payment record then shows the higher price as normal.
The key point is that a price above the PO is not always a duplicate or a fraud. It can be a stale PO or an unrecorded change. Either way, the payment leaves at the higher price and nobody owns the gap. That gap is the overpayment you need to find and recover.
Finding it
Start with paid invoices, not with open payables. Pull the paid invoice lines and compare the unit price on the invoice with the unit price on the PO and with the contract price. Look for lines where the paid price is higher. This is your invoice price variance view. Do it by supplier and by item so the pattern shows up.
A packaging supplier may show the same item paid above the PO across many invoices. A maintenance supplier may show a price that matches the PO but not the contract. Each is worth a look. Sort the exceptions by high-volume items before lower-volume items, because a small unit gap on an item bought often adds up faster. Then check the overrides. Look at the invoices that cleared on tolerance and the invoices where someone overrode the match. The override reason often points to the cause.
For each line, calculate the claim as the price difference times the quantity. Keep the PO or contract as evidence. If the receipt quantity is lower than the invoice quantity, separate the quantity issue from the price issue so the supplier can follow the claim. If the invoice includes a credit or a rebate, check that it was applied.
Contract price compliance review is the broader check: compare the paid price with the contract, not only with the PO. The PO can be stale, so the contract is the better evidence when they disagree. Keep a simple schedule by supplier, item, invoice, PO price, contract price, paid price and quantity. That schedule is what you send to the supplier and what you use to track recovery.
Asking the supplier for it
Ask for the money in writing, with the evidence attached. Address the supplier contact who owns the account, not the collections team. State the item, the PO or contract price, the billed price, the quantity and the invoice number. Ask them to confirm the price file and to issue a credit memo or a refund. Keep the tone factual. You are correcting a price, not accusing anyone.
If the supplier says the price changed, ask for the effective date and the written change that supports it. If the change is real and the PO was not updated, the gap may be internal. Update the PO and the vendor record so future invoices match. If the change is not documented, keep the difference in the claim. If the supplier offers a credit against future orders, check whether the contract allows that and whether the credit is applied to the right account.
Old claims need care. Time limits and recovery rights depend on the contract, the jurisdiction or an adviser. Do not guess. Put the claim in a tracker with the date sent, the supplier response and the next step. If the supplier disputes the quantity, split the price claim from the quantity claim and resolve each on its own evidence.
Use the same request for small and large gaps. A small unit difference on a high-volume item can be worth pursuing, just as a large difference on a special buy. Group the lines by supplier so the supplier sees the pattern, and ask for a consolidated credit memo that lists each invoice. That keeps the reconciliation simple for everyone.
Preventing it
Prevention starts with the PO and the contract price. When a buyer agrees a change, update the PO before the next invoice arrives. Keep the supplier price file aligned with the contract, and give someone clear ownership of that update. If the price file is out of date, AP will keep paying the old or new price by accident.
Set tight tolerances for high-volume items. The looser the tolerance, the more small differences clear without review. Tight tolerance does not mean every difference is a hold. It means the difference gets a reason code and a look before payment. Review tolerance exceptions by supplier each period. If a supplier keeps appearing, fix the price file or the PO.
Make overrides visible. Require a reason and an approver when someone clears a price exception. Review the override log for repeat suppliers and repeat buyers. If the override was right, update the PO so the next invoice does not need an override. If the override was wrong, the log shows where to recover.
Add a contract price compliance check to your regular AP review. Compare paid invoice prices with the contract for high-volume suppliers. Use the PO or contract as evidence, and keep a schedule of price differences. When a claim is recovered, use the credit memo to close the line. That closes the loop and stops the same gap from returning.
Questions
What is paying a price above the purchase order?
It is when an invoice bills a higher unit price than the PO and the difference is paid, often because it falls inside the invoice tolerance or because someone overrides the match. The quantity can match and the receipt can be clean. The gap sits in the unit price.
How do I calculate an overcharge claim?
Use the price difference times the quantity on the invoice or receipt. Keep the PO or contract as evidence, and list each invoice line so the supplier can trace it. If quantity is also in dispute, separate that from the price claim.
What if the supplier says the price increased?
Ask for the effective date and the written change that supports the new price. If the change is real, update the PO and the vendor record so future invoices match. If it is not documented, keep the difference in the claim.
Can we net an overcharge against the next invoice?
That depends on the contract and the supplier relationship, and it can create confusion if the next invoice is for different items. A credit memo or refund with a clear list of invoices is cleaner. Check the contract and ask an adviser if the amount is disputed.
Updated Nov 10, 2026. Figures on this page are calculated by ERPSav from the definitions shown. The explanatory text is drafted with AI from those figures and checked automatically before it is published. General information only, not legal, tax or financial advice.