In short
- Pro formas look like invoices and are often keyed as bills.
- The final invoice usually has a different number, so the duplicate check passes.
- Paying a pro forma should create a prepayment, not a bill.
- Matching on PO, supplier and amount links the two.
- International suppliers use pro formas for customs and prepayment, so imports are the usual case.
How it happens
A pro forma arrives before the goods ship. It looks like an invoice: supplier name, goods, amount and payment instructions. AP keys it as a bill because it came through the invoice inbox and the workflow expects a bill. The goods arrive later. The final invoice carries a different number. The duplicate check compares invoice numbers, so it passes. Payment goes out again. This is common with imports, where the supplier wants a prepayment and the pro forma supports customs paperwork.
A packaging supplier asks for payment on a pro forma to start a print run. AP pays it. Later, the final invoice arrives after shipment, with a new invoice number, the same PO and the same amount. If nobody applied the pro forma payment, AP pays the full amount again. The supplier may not flag it. The vendor statement can show a credit, but only if someone looks.
The root cause is simple. Paying a pro forma should create a prepayment against the PO and the vendor, not a bill. A bill sits in payables waiting to be paid. A prepayment sits against the order waiting to be applied. When the final invoice is keyed as a fresh bill, nothing links it to the earlier payment. The different invoice number hides the match.
Finding it in your payment history
Start with the payment history for import suppliers and any supplier that asks for prepayment. Look for payments to the same vendor close together, especially where the PO matches or the amounts look similar. The bank feed and the payment run report are enough to spot the pattern. Do not search by invoice number alone. The final invoice number will not match the pro forma number. Match on PO, supplier and amount instead.
Open the vendor record and look for unapplied prepayments or credits. If the pro forma was posted as a prepayment but never applied, the final invoice payment can still have gone out. Check the original pro forma, the remittance advice and any customs paperwork for the PO. The same goods and the same supplier are the clues.
A practical situation: a packaging supplier has a pro forma paid before production and a final invoice paid after shipment. The invoice numbers differ. The PO is the same. The amount is the same. Payment history shows the first payment cleared and the second payment cleared. That is the duplicate. If freight changed the final amount, match on PO and supplier, then check whether the prepayment was applied before the final payment went out.
Also check the inbox and the vendor file for pro formas that were never closed. A pro forma that was paid but not marked as applied is a live risk. The final invoice may be sitting in the approval queue now.
Getting the money back
Contact the supplier with the payment references, the pro forma, the final invoice, the PO and the remittance advice. Ask for a credit note or a refund. If you have open invoices with the supplier, ask them to apply the credit there. Get the agreement in writing so the vendor record can be updated. Keep the message factual: the pro forma payment and the final invoice payment show as cleared for the same PO and the same goods.
If the supplier calls the pro forma payment a deposit, check the contract and the vendor statement before you argue. A credit against future orders can be better than a refund, but compare the rate with your own cost of funds. Do not net off an invoice without the supplier's agreement. Bring in procurement or the relationship owner if the supplier resists. For cross-border payments, bank charges and currency conversion may affect the refund; the treatment depends on the contract, the jurisdiction or an adviser.
Once the supplier agrees, reconcile the vendor account. Apply the credit or refund to the right PO and clear the prepayment. If the final invoice was already paid, the credit may sit open until the next order. Record the cause so the same supplier does not repeat it. A short note in the vendor record helps the next AP clerk.
Stopping the next one
Change the intake rule first. A pro forma should go to a prepayment account against the PO and the vendor, not to the bill queue. The final invoice should not be released until the prepayment is applied. This is a process rule, not a system trick. If AP clerks cannot tell a pro forma from a bill, the duplicate will happen again.
Require a PO for every pro forma payment. Match on PO, supplier and amount. Keep a pro forma log that shows the supplier, the PO, the pro forma number, the payment date, the amount and the status. The log does not need to be complex. It needs to be checked before the payment run. When the final invoice arrives, the log shows whether the prepayment is still open.
Train approvers as well as AP clerks. A pro forma is a request for prepayment, not a final demand. Put a note in the vendor record for import suppliers that use pro formas. Ask suppliers to reference the pro forma number on the final invoice, but do not rely on it. The invoice number will often change.
Review open prepayments and unapplied vendor credits on a regular cycle. Do it before the payment run, not after. If a prepayment has no final invoice after a long period, ask the supplier for a statement. The contract, the jurisdiction or an adviser will govern any claim for a refund. The goal is to catch the gap while the supplier still has an open balance.
Questions
What is a pro forma invoice?
A pro forma invoice is a supplier's preliminary document that shows goods, terms and payment instructions before shipment or final billing. It is not a demand for final payment in the same way as a commercial invoice. AP teams often receive it for imports because the supplier wants prepayment and customs paperwork.
Should a pro forma invoice be entered as a bill?
No. Paying a pro forma should create a prepayment against the PO and vendor, not a bill. If you key it as a bill, the final invoice can pass duplicate checks because it has a different number. Then the same goods get paid again unless someone applies the prepayment.
How do I find a duplicate pro forma payment?
Search payment history by supplier, PO and amount, not by invoice number. Look for a pro forma payment and a final invoice payment to the same vendor on the same PO. Check the vendor record for unapplied prepayments or credits. Matching on PO, supplier and amount links the payments.
How do I stop pro forma duplicates in AP?
Treat pro formas as prepayments and require a PO before payment. Hold the final invoice until the prepayment is applied to it. Match on PO, supplier and amount, and keep a pro forma log that shows what is open.
Updated Nov 9, 2026. Figures on this page are calculated by ERPSav from the definitions shown. The explanatory text is drafted with AI from those figures and checked automatically before it is published. General information only, not legal, tax or financial advice.