Recovery playbooks · Overpayments

Freight charged twice or on a prepaid shipment

Freight charged twice is a freight charge on the supplier invoice and again on a carrier invoice for the same shipment, or freight billed on an order where the supplier agreed to pay it.

In short

  • Freight terms on the PO or contract decide who pays it.
  • Supplier invoices that add freight to prepaid orders are a common overcharge.
  • Carrier invoices paid separately for the same shipment double the cost.
  • Matching freight lines to shipments and freight terms shows what was paid twice or not owed.
  • Freight terms printed on every PO and checked at invoice entry stop most of it.

How the overpayment happens

Freight terms on the PO or contract decide who pays it. When the PO says freight prepaid, the supplier has agreed to cover the freight and build it into the price or absorb it. The buyer should not pay a separate freight line on the supplier invoice, and should not pay a carrier invoice for that shipment. The trouble starts when the terms live in a contract file or an email and the PO just says freight as agreed. AP then has nothing to check at invoice entry, so the freight line gets coded and paid.

A packaging supplier can bill the goods with a freight line even though the PO says prepaid, or simply add a freight charge because the shipment went out by a carrier. The carrier then sends its own invoice for the same delivery, often to the wrong address or to a plant contact, and someone pays it without linking it to the PO. Now the same shipment has freight on the supplier invoice and freight on the carrier invoice. Neither clerk sees the duplicate because the supplier invoice sits in the vendor record and the carrier invoice sits in the carrier file.

Prepaid orders are the common overcharge because the supplier invoice looks ordinary. The freight line is small, the goods are right, and the invoice matches the PO on everything except the freight. AP pays the line because it is on the invoice and the receiver signed for the delivery. The carrier invoice later looks ordinary too. Without the terms and the shipment reference together, the double charge is invisible.

Finding it

Start with the freight terms, not the invoice. Pull the PO or contract for a sample of shipments and note who pays freight. Then pull the supplier invoice and the carrier invoice for the same shipment. Match the freight line to the shipment, the PO and the terms. If the PO says the supplier pays, any freight line on the supplier invoice is not owed. If the carrier invoice names the same shipment, it is a duplicate charge. That is the simple test.

The matching is easier when you use the shipment reference. A bill of lading number, a tracking number, a delivery date and a ship-to address can tie the supplier invoice and the carrier invoice together. AP often has these details but keeps them in different places. A carrier invoice may show only the shipper's reference, not your PO number, so the clerk pays it as a standalone freight bill. Put the shipment reference on the payment record and the duplicate becomes visible.

Look for freight lines on invoices for orders that should be prepaid. A supplier that sells packaging or parts may add freight to every invoice as a habit. Check the vendor record for the freight terms and the PO history. If the same supplier has added freight to prepaid orders before, widen the check to other invoices from that supplier. Also check the carrier invoices for shipments that the supplier already billed with freight. The question is not whether freight is legitimate in general. It is whether this shipment carried a freight charge that the terms put on the supplier.

Asking the supplier for it

Send the supplier a short claim with the documents. Reference the PO, the invoice, the freight line and the freight term. Say what you expected and what you paid. If the supplier invoiced freight on a prepaid order, ask for a credit memo for the freight line. If the carrier invoiced you separately for the same shipment, attach the carrier invoice and ask the supplier to confirm who booked and paid the carrier. Keep the claim factual and specific. A supplier is more likely to credit a clear line than a general complaint about freight.

Route the claim to the right person. AP clerks often send disputes to the sales rep or the collections contact, where they sit. Ask for the name of the person who owns freight billing or the accounts receivable team. Put the PO number and the invoice number in the subject line. Give a response date that fits your payment terms and your own follow-up cycle. Do not withhold the whole invoice if only the freight line is in dispute. Pay the undisputed goods and hold the freight line, or follow the contract terms if the contract allows a setoff.

If the supplier will not credit the freight, ask for the carrier invoice or the prepaid freight evidence. The supplier may have paid the carrier and added the cost, even though the PO said prepaid. The terms decide. If the contract is unclear, escalate to the buyer or contract owner and get advice where the amount or the relationship matters. Record the outcome in the vendor record. A credit memo closes the claim. A refusal with a reason tells you what to check next time.

Preventing it

Put the freight terms on every PO. Use plain language: who pays freight and who books the carrier. Say whether the supplier may add freight to the invoice. If the order is freight prepaid, say so on the PO and on the release. The buyer should not leave freight terms in a side email. AP cannot enforce a term that never reaches the PO. A short freight block on the PO is enough for the clerk to check at invoice entry. Freight terms printed on every PO and checked at invoice entry stop most of it.

Check freight at invoice entry, not after payment. The clerk should see the freight line and the PO term together. If the PO says the supplier pays freight, the clerk holds the line and asks for a credit before posting. If the PO allows freight, the clerk checks the carrier invoice and the shipment reference so the same freight is not paid twice. A simple hold reason works: freight prepaid, credit pending. The goal is to stop the payment before it leaves, because recovery after payment takes longer.

Give the carrier invoices a home. If carriers invoice the plant directly, AP may never see the charge until the plant sends it for payment. Ask carriers to quote the PO number and the shipment reference on every invoice. Route carrier invoices to AP, not to the receiving desk. Reconcile the carrier invoices against the supplier invoices for prepaid shipments. And train receivers to note who paid the freight on the delivery record. Prevention is mostly a paperwork habit: put the terms on the PO and make the shipment reference part of the invoice check.

Questions

How do I know if freight was charged twice?

Compare the freight line on the supplier invoice with the freight terms on the PO and with any carrier invoice for the same shipment. If the PO says the supplier pays freight, a supplier freight line is not owed. If a carrier also billed the same shipment, you have a duplicate. Use the shipment reference to tie the documents together.

What does freight prepaid mean on a supplier invoice?

Freight prepaid means the supplier has agreed to pay the carrier and should not add a separate freight charge to the invoice. The exact meaning depends on the contract and the freight terms on the PO. If the invoice adds freight anyway, ask for the term and the carrier evidence. Do not assume the line is valid because the goods arrived.

Can we recover freight charged on a prepaid shipment?

Yes, ask the supplier for a credit memo for the freight line, with the PO and invoice attached. Recovery depends on the contract, the evidence and the supplier's response. If the supplier refuses, escalate to the buyer or contract owner and get advice where needed. Record the outcome so the next invoice gets checked.

Who should pay the carrier invoice when the PO says freight prepaid?

The supplier should pay the carrier if the PO puts freight on the supplier. AP should not pay a carrier invoice for that shipment. If a carrier invoice arrives, match it to the PO and the shipment reference, then send it to the supplier or hold it until the freight responsibility is clear. Paying it first and asking later makes recovery harder.

Updated Nov 10, 2026. Figures on this page are calculated by ERPSav from the definitions shown. The explanatory text is drafted with AI from those figures and checked automatically before it is published. General information only, not legal, tax or financial advice.