Recovery playbooks · Duplicate payments

Paying the same invoice by check and by ACH

A supplier switching from checks to ACH, or a check reissued electronically, can leave one invoice paid once each way.

In short

  • The two payments come from different payment methods, so a review of one method's register will not show the pair.
  • It often happens when a check is reported lost and an ACH is sent before the check is stopped.
  • Comparing payments to the same vendor across all methods, by invoice and amount, finds them.
  • Voiding the check in the ERP and stopping it at the bank must happen before the replacement goes out.
  • Positive pay catches the original check if it is presented later.

How it happens

The mistake starts when the payment method changes mid-stream. A supplier asks to move from checks to ACH. AP updates the vendor record and pays open invoices by ACH, but an earlier check run already produced a check for one of those invoices. The check is not voided in the ERP or stopped at the bank. The supplier deposits it, and the invoice is paid by both methods. The check payment and the ACH payment come from different payment methods, so a review of one method's register will not show the pair.

Lost-check replacements are another common route. A supplier reports a check lost. AP sends an ACH payment before the check is stopped. If the original check later turns up and is presented, the bank may pay it unless positive pay or a stop payment blocks it. The replacement was recorded as a new payment, not as a continuation of the original, so the invoice now has a check and an ACH against it. The same happens when a check is reissued electronically but the old check remains open.

Check runs and ACH files may be handled by different people. A replacement request arrives by email, gets keyed as a new payment, and no one ties it back to the original check. Supplier remittance advice lists the invoice once, so the supplier may not notice the duplicate either. The vendor record may hold both check and ACH details, and the payment method is changed without reviewing open items. The mistake is procedural, not exotic.

Finding it in your payment history

A check register alone will not show it. An ACH register alone will not show it. Compare payments to the same vendor across all methods, by invoice and amount. Use the vendor record as the starting point, then pull check payments, ACH payments and any manual payments for that vendor. Look for the same invoice number, or a close variant, appearing as a check payment and as an ACH payment. Match amounts, invoice dates, purchase order references and remittance details. Include voided and stopped items, because a check voided in the ERP may still have been presented.

A packaging supplier reports that a check was lost. AP sends an ACH payment before the check is stopped. Later the check clears. The check register shows the original check as outstanding until the bank statement arrives. The ACH file shows the replacement. Reconciling the bank statement to the ERP brings the check back, but only if someone compares that cleared check to the ACH payment for the same invoice. The vendor statement may show both receipts, or the supplier may apply the ACH as a credit and leave the invoice open, which hides the duplicate from a quick aging review.

Look at timing. A check and an ACH payment close together for the same invoice are a warning. Also look for a replacement payment with no corresponding void or stop. Review positive pay exceptions, because a check presented after a replacement was issued may appear there. Ask suppliers for statements and confirm open items. Watch for invoice number formatting differences, credits applied to the wrong invoice, and payments split across methods. If the vendor record was updated from check to ACH, review all open checks for that vendor before the next ACH run.

Getting the money back

Confirm the duplicate before calling. Gather the check image, the ACH trace or bank advice, the vendor record, the invoice and the remittance advice. If the check has not been presented, stop payment at the bank and void the check in the ERP. The order matters: voiding in the ERP and stopping it at the bank must happen before the replacement goes out. If the replacement already went out, stop the original check now and ask the bank about returning the ACH payment. Whether an ACH can be returned depends on the bank's rules and the timing, so confirm with your bank rather than assuming.

Contact the supplier with proof of the check and the ACH and a clear request: refund the duplicate, apply it as a credit to open invoices, or offset it against the next payment. A packaging supplier might prefer a credit; a services supplier might refund. Put the request in writing and reference the invoice, check number and ACH reference. If the supplier has already applied the ACH as a credit, ask them to reverse the credit and refund the check payment, or the other way around. Keep the vendor record current so the credit is not lost.

If the supplier does not respond, escalate through the account manager and your procurement contact. Use the contract terms to guide the conversation; remedies depend on the contract and the jurisdiction. Do not net a disputed duplicate against unrelated invoices without agreement. Document the recovery and update the vendor record. If the duplicate is found after a supplier statement reconciliation, fix the open item so the aging report is accurate. Positive pay can catch the original check if it is presented later, but it does not recover an ACH payment already received.

Stopping the next one

Treat a payment method change as a control event. When a supplier moves from checks to ACH, review open checks and outstanding items before the first ACH run. Confirm that old checks are voided in the ERP and stopped at the bank before any replacement goes out. Require approval for the method change and record it on the vendor record. Do not let a replacement payment be keyed as a new invoice payment without a link to the original. The person who changes the vendor record should not be the only person who releases the payment.

Use positive pay and reconcile it. Positive pay catches the original check if it is presented later, but only if the exception is reviewed promptly and matched to the replacement. Reconcile the check register to the bank statement and the ACH file to the bank advice. Compare payments to the same vendor across all methods, by invoice and amount, before closing the period. Look for a check and an ACH payment for the same invoice, and for replacement payments with no void or stop.

Make the supplier part of the control. Ask suppliers to confirm payment method changes in writing and to report a lost check before cashing a replacement. Send remittance advice that lists invoice numbers and payment methods. When a supplier says a check is lost, check the vendor record and the check register before sending an ACH. If the check is still open, stop it first. If it has cleared, do not replace it. Train AP clerks on the sequence: verify, stop, void, then replace. The goal is not more reports; it is one payment per invoice across every method.

Questions

Can a supplier cash a check and also receive an ACH for the same invoice?

Yes. If a check is reported lost and an ACH replacement is sent before the check is stopped, the original check can still be presented and paid. The invoice then has a check payment and an ACH payment against it. Positive pay or a stop payment may block the check, but only if the stop is in place before presentment.

How do I find duplicate payments made by check and ACH?

Compare payments to the same vendor across all methods, by invoice and amount. Pull the check register, the ACH file and the bank statements, and match invoice numbers, amounts and remittance details. Look for a check and an ACH payment close together, and for replacement payments with no void or stop.

What should I do if a supplier says the check was lost and I already sent an ACH?

Stop the original check at the bank and void it in the ERP now. Ask the bank about returning the ACH payment if the check has already cleared. Contact the supplier with proof of the check and the ACH and request a refund or credit. Document the recovery and update the vendor record.

Does positive pay stop a duplicate check payment?

Positive pay can catch the original check if it is presented after a replacement was issued. It does not stop an ACH payment that has already been received. Review positive pay exceptions promptly and match them to replacement payments. A stop payment at the bank is still needed when a check is replaced.

Updated Nov 8, 2026. Figures on this page are calculated by ERPSav from the definitions shown. The explanatory text is drafted with AI from those figures and checked automatically before it is published. General information only, not legal, tax or financial advice.