Recovery playbooks · Overpayments

A credit agreed by email that never reached AP

A credit agreed by email and never passed to AP: the buyer or manager settles a damage, late delivery or service issue with the supplier, and AP pays the invoice in full.

In short

  • Credits agreed for damage, late delivery or service problems are often settled in email.
  • The supplier may issue a credit note that goes to the requester, not AP.
  • Asking suppliers for a statement shows credits issued but not taken.
  • The agreement email is enough evidence to ask for the credit.
  • A rule that all agreed credits are sent to AP stops it.

How the overpayment happens

The overpayment starts with a problem that is real but small enough to settle in email. A packaging supplier delivers cartons crushed at the corner. The warehouse tells the buyer. The buyer emails the supplier's account manager, who agrees to credit the damaged cartons on the next invoice. Nobody copies AP. The next invoice arrives for the full amount, AP matches it to the purchase order and receipt, sees no reason to hold it, and pays. The credit sits in a mailbox.

A variation is a price reduction agreed for late delivery or a service problem. The supplier may issue a credit note, but it goes to the person who raised the issue, not to AP. The requester files it, forgets it, or assumes AP has it. AP sees only the invoice and the vendor record, and the vendor record has no note about the agreement.

The supplier may also apply the credit to a later invoice without telling anyone. AP pays that later invoice in full because the invoice does not show the credit. The supplier keeps the payment as an open credit or applies it somewhere else. The buyer believes the matter is closed. AP has no idea a credit exists.

Finding it

Start with supplier statements. Ask for a statement of account from active suppliers, not just the large ones. A statement shows credits issued but not taken, including credits that never reached your ledger. Compare the statement to your vendor record and to open invoices. A credit line with no matching credit in your records is a lead.

Search the requesters' mailboxes with their help. Look for words like credit, credit note, damage, return, short delivery, price adjustment and goodwill. Ask each buyer and manager to search their own sent and received folders for agreements they made. A short list is enough.

Check the vendor record for notes that never became a credit. A note such as 'supplier agreed to credit' is evidence of a conversation, not a credit taken. Match it to a credit note, an invoice reduction or a refund. If none exist, put the item on a list. For each item, write the supplier, the invoice or order it relates to, the person who agreed it, and the evidence you hold.

Asking the supplier for it

Use the agreement email as your evidence. Send it to the supplier's account manager and ask for a credit note made out to your legal entity, with the invoice or order reference and the reason. Ask where the credit note was sent. If it went to the requester, ask for a copy and ask the supplier to send future credit notes to AP.

Be specific about what you want. Ask the supplier to apply the credit to an open invoice, offset it against the next payment, or refund it. The right route depends on the contract and the supplier's process, so confirm it in writing. Keep the request factual: the date of the agreement, the problem, the amount if the email states it, and the invoice it relates to.

If the supplier says the credit was already applied, ask for the credit note number and the invoice it was applied to. Check that invoice against your payment record. If the credit was applied to an invoice you paid in full, ask the supplier to move it to an open invoice or refund it. If the supplier has no record, send the email thread again and ask for a statement of account.

Preventing it

Make one rule: every credit agreed by email goes to AP. Put that rule in the purchase order terms, the supplier onboarding pack and the requester training. Ask suppliers to send credit notes to the AP mailbox, not to the buyer, and to quote the invoice or order reference. Give requesters a simple habit: forward the email to AP in the same thread and add the supplier, the reason and the invoice or order.

Log the credit in the vendor record as an open credit. It stays open until it is matched to a credit note, applied to an invoice or refunded. Review supplier statements on a regular cycle. A statement check catches credits that went to a requester or were applied to a later invoice. Add a note to the vendor record when a supplier agrees a credit, and clear the note only when the credit is taken.

Separate the person who agrees the credit from the person who pays. A buyer can agree a commercial settlement, but AP should see it before payment. If a credit is agreed after an invoice is paid, AP needs a refund or a credit to an open invoice. Close the loop in writing so the next invoice does not repeat the problem.

Questions

What is a credit agreed by email that never reached AP?

It is a credit, price reduction or credit note agreed between a buyer or manager and a supplier in email, where AP is not copied and the invoice is paid in full. The supplier's ledger shows the credit; your vendor record does not.

How do I recover a supplier credit that was agreed in an email?

Send the email thread to the supplier's account manager and ask for a credit note made out to your legal entity, with the invoice or order reference. Ask for the credit to be applied to an open invoice or refunded, and confirm the route in writing. Log it as an open credit until it is taken.

What if the supplier says the credit was already applied?

Ask for the credit note number and the invoice it was applied to, then check that invoice against your payment record. If you paid that invoice in full, ask the supplier to move the credit to an open invoice or refund it. Ask for a statement of account if the supplier has no record.

Should AP accept a credit note sent to the requester?

Yes, if it is valid and matches the agreement. Ask the requester to forward the credit note and the email trail to AP, and ask the supplier to send future credit notes to the AP mailbox. AP should match the credit note to the invoice or order before treating it as taken.

Updated Nov 11, 2026. Figures on this page are calculated by ERPSav from the definitions shown. The explanatory text is drafted with AI from those figures and checked automatically before it is published. General information only, not legal, tax or financial advice.